Earlier this year, late-night TV host Jimmy Kimmel asked parents to tell their children they ate all their Halloween candy, film the results and upload it to Youtube. Now, he’s issued another challenge to gift children something early, film them opening it and again, upload the results. The catch: the gift has to be terrible. Parents got to work and wrapped all kinds of horrible things for their excited kids including a battery, an onion, a half-eaten PBJ sandwich, a Waffle House hat and more. The children’s confused (and sometimes angry) reactions are hilarious.